EDUC 522 Week 3: Using Benchmarks to Drive Performance
Introduction
Setting goals and targets to drive
organizational performance is a common problem solving strategy in both the private
and public sectors. Although setting “stretch
goals” has been shown to work in a few isolated cases, data driven benchmarking
is the preferred and more common approach.
A benchmark is a reachable, objective, and reliable categorization or numerical scale by which organizational
performance is assessed. There are two ways
to benchmark organizational performance: peer-based benchmarking and standards-based
benchmarking. In peer-based benchmarking, similar or aspirational peer organizations are used as performance benchmarks. For
example, a private research university such as USC might benchmark its student retention
rate to that of peer institutions such as Stanford, Harvard and Yale. The second
way to benchmark is to use objectively determined standards of performance. For
example, a Title I school might target resources to assure that 100% of its students
meet the “basic” level on the standardized tests.
Unit
learning goals
When you finish this unit you will
have learned to:
1. Use peer-based benchmarking to solve
a variety of accountability problems in K-12 education, higher education and industry.
2.
Use
standards-based benchmarking to solve a variety of accountability problems in K-12
education, higher education and industry.
Questions to answer before class as
you complete your reading assignment:
1. Use both peer-based benchmarking and
standards-based benchmarking to begin to solve an accountability problem that you
have identified.
Unit 3 ppt.
Marsh, J. A. (2012). Interventions promoting educators’ use of data: Research
insights and gaps. Teachers College Record, 114(11), 1–48.
Gladwell, M. (2011). The order of things. The New Yorker, 69-75
Dowd, A. C., (2005). Data don’t drive:
Building a practitioner-driven culture of inquiry to assess community college performance.
Boston: University of Massachusetts, Lumina Foundation for Education.
College Scorecard. https://collegescorecard.ed.gov/
Bogue, E. G., & Hall, K. (2003). College rankings and ratings: The test
of reputation. In E.G. Bogue & K. Hall (Eds.), Quality and accountability in higher education: Improving policy, enhancing
performance (pp. 51-75). Westport, CT:
Praeger.